download autocad electrical 2008 adobe indesign cs2 download buy microsoft streets and trips 2010 buy ms powerpoint buy visio 2003 professional adobe premiere elements cheap windows 2008 server prices adobe premiere elements 8 buy buy windows 7 oem buy 3ds max 9 buy windows 2008 server r2 buy illustrator for mac buy windows 7 half price buy premiere elements 7 cheap windows 7 download microsoft mappoint 2009 price microsoft office 2003 pro oem download corel video studio 11 adobe cs3 for mac buy corel video studio pro x2 cubase 4 download full cheap windows vista business after effects cs4 download cheap autocad software buy photoimpact x3 buy autodesk 3ds max cheap buy photoshop cs4 download powerpoint cheap when can i buy office 2010 download adobe after effects cs3 download autocad mechanical 2010 download inventor lt 2010 autocad inventor price 3ds max design 2009 buy premiere pro cs4 money plus home & business microsoft office project professional 2007 download steinberg cubase sx3 download buy powerpoint only buy photoshop cs4 student purchase visual studio 2008 professional buy contribute cs4 microsoft mappoint europe 2006 download streets and trips 2010 price adobe production premium mac purchase office 2003 product key adobe premiere pro price indesign software download download dreamweaver cs4 download wavelab 6 office 2003 for sale buy microsoft project 2007 professional buy windows 2003 enterprise edition buy visual studio 2005 pro autodesk navisworks download adobe cs4 production premium download 3ds max sale adobe cs3 web premium download adobe premiere pro download autodesk inventor lt buy windows 7 professional cheap download encarta encyclopedia 2009 lightroom for mac os x buy microsoft access 97 autocad electrical 2009 download purchase corel draw 12 purchase vista operating system buy access 2007 only purchase windows 7 volume license download illustrator for mac buy microsoft word 2003 software buy windows 7 license online cheap adobe illustrator cs4 download adobe captivate 3 buy microsoft project 2007 purchase adobe after effects purchase photoshop elements download corel dvd moviefactory 6 windows vista business 64 bit iso buy cheap windows 7 ultimate inventor professional 2010 download purchase vista online buy streets and trips 2010 best buy photoshop microsoft office 2003 best buy purchase adobe lightroom cheap norton ghost how to buy windows 7 64 bit windows 7 home premium best buy purchase windows 7 home premium windows vista home basic product key buy microsoft frontpage 2007 steinberg nuendo 4 download windows enterprise price buy quickbooks online buy windows 7 pro oem cheap windows 7 professional adobe flash cs4 for mac download download corel draw 13 cheap windows vista 64 bit steinberg cubase 5 price adobe captivate pricing mappoint 2009 european microsoft encarta premium 2009 download download microsoft mappoint 2009 cheap windows 7 home premium full version buy microsoft works 9.0 powerpoint pricing corel draw mac version cheapest windows xp professional dreamweaver mac cs4 autocad electrical price purchase microsoft word coreldraw x4 mac turbo tax 2009 download buy illustrator cs2 cheap vista business adobe premiere pro mac buy windows 7 starter download microsoft office 2008 for mac illustrator download cs3 download maya 2009 font folio 11 download buy adobe photoshop mac buy autodesk inventor microsoft windows 7 home premium buy cubase 5 cost adobe contribute cs4 mac price buy windows 7 ultimate cheap adobe after effects cs3 price adobe indesign cs4 mac buy vista home premium product key microsoft office 2010 price windows 7 ultimate price uk buy windows 7 ultimate student download autocad 2010 quicken rental property manager 2009 coupon download adobe illustrator for mac buy adobe photoshop for mac buy adobe acrobat 9 pro extended cs4 master collection download windows vista home premium download buy cs3 after effects microsoft money 2007 home & business download fireworks cs4 microsoft windows 7 home premium 64 bit oem windows vista business oem download windows 7 buy online download dreamweaver mac demo buy vista ultimate oem autodesk maya 2009 buy buy mappoint 2010 cheap windows 7 ultimate retail buy adobe robohelp 8 buy adobe cs3 cheap buy dreamweaver cs3 zonealarm antivirus 8 trial buy microsoft office 2003 professional purchase after effects buy powerpoint 2003 download adobe robohelp download buy acrobat professional 9 adobe captivate oem buy framemaker norton 360 discount download autodesk maya microsoft office 2010 download pcanywhere pricing microsoft office 2003 full download buy adobe indesign cs4 autodesk inventor professional 2008 download microsoft windows 7 ultimate cheap buy access 2003 software contribute cs4 download how to get photoshop for cheap purchase windows vista ultimate key autocad mechanical price adobe illustrator cs4 sale buy windows xp sp3 oem purchase windows xp service pack 3 ms streets and trips 2009 download corel video studio pro x2 download buy windows 7 64 bit online buy visio 2003 buy autocad 2009 cheap indesign cs3 illustrator cs2 download windows 7 professional 64 bit price buy powerpoint 2007 only microsoft excel 2003 download buy 3ds max online autodesk lustre price buy quicken online autodesk inventor lt 2010 price buy windows vista home basic product key microsoft frontpage sale wordperfect download purchase corel draw autodesk 3ds max price buy vista get windows 7 corel draw 12 mac windows 7 ultimate 32bit system requirements dvd moviefactory 6 plus buy cs3 cheap download turbotax 2008 premier adobe illustrator cs3 price windows 2003 enterprise license cost adobe cs4 design premium trial where can i buy powerpoint 2003 adobe presenter 7 download cubase 4 price cheap illustrator cs4 buy acrobat standard windows 7 home premium oem price windows 7 professional 32-bit oem buy adobe illustrator student visual studio 2008 download adobe cs3 master collection system requirements buy quicken 2010 deluxe buy visio 2007 autodesk 3ds max 2010 system requirements buy microsoft office project professional 2003 corel draw 10 mac microsoft office enterprise 2007 price windows 2008 server purchase buy microsoft office for mac online adobe premiere pro cs4 buy purchase windows 7 licence microsoft expression pricing windows 7 professional discount buy adobe acrobat 9 professional buy word 2007 download cheap lightroom corel software for mac microsoft windows vista home basic with sp2 (64 bit) adobe after effects mac download adobe creative suite 4 production premium mac streets and trips 2010 buy buy adobe premiere pro cs4 download after effects cs4 portable buy microsoft expression studio 2 buy photoshop cs4 extended download adobe cs4 design premium mac buy outlook 2007 only wavelab 6 price adobe indesign cs3 mac visio 2007 buy buy turbotax deluxe buy windows 7 ultimate full buy adobe illustrator cs2 download corel draw graphics suite x4 buy microsoft expression blend 3 buy adobe photoshop cs3 extended purchase adobe captivate 3 purchase cubase 4 windows 7 ultimate cheap windows vista download iso buy lightroom download buy photoshop cheap purchase windows xp pro autocad electrical 2010 trial adobe cs4 design premium mac buy corel dvd moviefactory 7 download download windows 2008 r2 buy outlook express 2007 after effects mac demo buy microsoft expression studio 3 cheap acrobat professional adobe lightroom cheap buy dreamweaver 8 autocad architecture pricing mappoint europe 2010 purchase ms office online purchase vista ultimate windows 7 professional price uk norton ghost price illustrator cs3 download buy microsoft office 2003 student buy autosketch 9 after effects student discount adobe illustrator cs4 price cheapest microsoft office buy microsoft excel online windows 7 home premium full discount windows 2008 enterprise cost windows 7 ultimate purchase download quicken 2010 buy windows 7 oem ultimate torrent adobe illustrator mac download microsoft windows 7 home premium best buy adobe after effects demo adobe cs4 web premium download buy microsoft money online buy windows 7 home basic turbotax 2009 deals buy norton 360 cheap buy adobe illustrator cs3 autocad electrical 2008 download download photoshop elements cubase sx3 price autocad architecture download download photoshop elements 6 download photoshop mac windows 7 ultimate 32bit trial buy vista ultimate online after effects cs4 for mac coreldraw graphics suite x4 for mac cheap photoshop software windows 7 best buy buy autocad lt 2010 adobe indesign cs3 cheap purchase vista oem cheapest windows 7 price microsoft office 2003 sale buy cs3 dreamweaver windows 7 professional 32 bit download buy windows 7 cheap buy microsoft streets and trips 2009 photoshop elements download windows 7 ultimate oem pricing download corel painter x mac buy sql server 2008 developer edition corel draw x4 full download excel 2003 price download microsoft frontpage 2003 buy quicken rental property manager microsoft excel 2007 download microsoft money buy online illustrator for mac os x cheapest windows 7 ultimate windows 7 ultimate 64 bit download adobe cs4 design premium price microsoft access 2003 download adobe robohelp 8 download microsoft word 2007 price quicken rental property manager 2010 download buy microsoft word 2003 download buy encarta 2009 indesign software order windows 7 ultimate buy office 2003 key autodesk 3ds max 2009 download windows 7 professional oem price buy adobe illustrator mac expression studio price turbotax 2008 premier download turbotax premier discount windows 7 home premium coupon dreamweaver mac cs3 adobe cs4 design premium mac download cheapest windows 7 professional buy microsoft access 2003 microsoft visio 2007 pro cheap adobe cs4 mac windows 7 home premium 32 bit oem acrobat pricing microsoft windows vista home premium with sp2 (64 bit) buy cubase sx3 buy adobe flash 8 buy photoshop mac download adobe audition 2.0 download adobe creative suite 4 master collection framemaker price buy cs3 design premium buy powerpoint 2007 download download fireworks cs3 windows vista home basic 32 bit download autodesk autocad architecture 2010 download buy windows 7 professional 64 bit cs4 production premium mac microsoft expression buy microsoft onenote pricing buy windows 7 now buy after effects cs4 buy microsoft outlook 2007 windows xp buy download where to buy microsoft office cheap adobe acrobat prices microsoft office 2003 buy download buy microsoft access 2007 download quickbooks enterprise 9.0 price download wordperfect buy windows xp pro windows 7 ultimate best buy windows vista premium download photoshop cs3 price buy cubase 5 online quickbooks enterprise 9.0 download download adobe audition 3 full version adobe illustrator cs3 sale buy autodesk inventor 2008 purchase acrobat 9 buy autodesk 3ds max design windows 7 home premium sale buy windows 7 ultimate key buy photoshop for cheap buy excel 2003 online visio 2007 pricing buy maya software streets and trips 2009 download adobe creative suite 4 web premium download buy adobe fireworks cs4 where to buy quicken 2010 buy photoshop elements cheap windows 7 home premium 64 bit download master collection cs4 student buy windows 7 oem cheap cheap adobe photoshop cs3 photoshop cs3 pricing buy windows 7 ultimate online windows 7 ultimate buy online buy adobe premiere pro for mac buy adobe captivate 4 buy 3ds max cheap buy indesign cs4 buy wordperfect 11 encarta premium 2009 download how to buy adobe presenter buy adobe master collection cs3 adobe premiere pro cs4 download download streets and trips 2007 adobe cs3 cheap buy microsoft project professional 2007 buy adobe cs3 design premium adobe photoshop cs4 buy microsoft word 2007 product key buy flash cs3 buy outlook 2007 cheap buy windows vista home premium purchase windows 7 license online windows 2003 enterprise license price corel dvd moviefactory 7 download purchase windows 7 license where to buy quickbooks enterprise purchase microsoft vista buy acrobat 8 buy adobe master collection cs4 windows 7 ultimate 64 bit iso buy vista premium buy norton 360 key microsoft office 2003 best price buy windows 7 premium download navisworks quicken 2010 price purchase quickbooks windows 7 pro discount buy dreamweaver for mac buy microsoft office 2003 pro buy ms project 2003 encarta 2009 full download pcanywhere download 12.5


In which we see a bunch of pictures and slap-dash commentary, in the small sandwich of time I have before my childcare ends.

First off, look at that JumboTron, will ya? And do you like the fascinating simulacrum effect of the imagery of justice (or the pursuit of it), superimposed on the front of City Hall? This is the future and there it is, 20′ x 30′ or whatever.

This gal had a fabulous two part sign. What’s not to like about a youngster walking around with a big poster of Harvey Milk, who was assassinated long before she was even born (”We don’t walk in your shadow, we grow in your shade.”) Now look at the flip side. (”Please give my mom the right to watch her 4 out of 5 gay kids get married.”) Sweet, eh? And look at that wonderful smile. You can’t see it, but that’s a piercing on her lip. And yes, we all have no idea which of the five she is. Part of the wonderfulness that is the future of our great nation.

It was a freakin’ zoo there. And this was the calm locale. We were facing City Hall, watching the JumboTron and frequently breaking out into applause, etc. Over in front of the state Court House, the Yes on 8 crowd had clumped, in order to provide the exiting attorneys lots of, mmm. What’s the best thing to call it? Yes: harassment. With more time, I could do a specific series on the MARRIAGE STILL = 1 MAN + 1 WOMAN sign, and the evolving drama of folks holding counter signs in front of it. (See it, big & black & white, to the left there?). Eventually the hetero math sign holder got it hoisted on two wooden sticks, ostensibly making the logic of his point unassailable by virtue of its height. (Voilá the sign before makeover and after.)

The future lies in good hands, and the hands are on a cell phone. I was near a clump of folks, college age, and most, by my eye, I would guess were heterosexual allies. They were in good cheer, unlike me, who was often sick to my stomach listening to the amount of time Justice Kennard interrupted the attorneys attempting to argue the unconstitutionality of the proposition. When the JumboTron flickered out for a moment, they offered “What do we want? JumboTron? When do we want it? Now!”

But a bunch of their group came over after having spent some time in the Yes on 8 hornet’s nest a block away. They said, “We were teaching them the bible. We totally knew passages better than they did.” Like I said, the future’s in good hands.

Proud mom, sandwiched between factions who want her son to be divorced. You know, because they care about marraige. Go, mom.  Another favorite sign, for me: “Jesus had two dads, why can’t I?”  I also liked this one held by someone from the Progressive Jewish Alliance: “We are the Jewish community: we pray with our feet.” Another sister with her had a t-shirt that read, “To kvetch is human; to act, divine.”

We were to wear white in solidarity. I forgot, but this gal did not. A flair for accessorizing helps.

My hero, Shannon Minter, in action, here, providing rebuttal to Ken Starr.

Molly McKay, Media Director of Marriage Equality USA led the crowd in cheers for the attorneys after the arguments closed. (You can’t see here in this, but trust me, she’s there.) She urged us to peacefully mosey over and greet our folks as they exited the courthouse. Not easy, the peaceful part, given the welter of Yes folks chanting / yelling.

Here we are, traipsing peacefully to the cranky shout-off in front of the court house. One of the affable hetero ally youngsters (yep, it has come to this: college students are now “youngsters” to me) was remarking on the bodaciousness of the red boots (shown above), and claiming he’d love to have come to the event in them. I got the impression he didn’t have much practice walking in equipment like that, and I told him, Brother, that is not for the faint of heart! Then I pointed to my excessively sensible shoes.

Melee. Basically. Take my word for it, since my lack of telephoto gives you little sense except that yes, the PROTECT TRADITIONAL MARRIAGE signs were about the dimension of a twin-sized bed.  Just in case one might think they didn’t feel strongly about the matter.  One word came to mind, as “No on 8″ / “Yes on 8″ chants were competing for every spare inch in the brain: Babel.

I was glad there was no more space on that side of the street.  [Get a load of the view from the courthouse steps, at the top of the NYT article on the day.] Still, I could hear some of the inspirational verbiage from our folks at the podium. Attorney Gloria Allred, flanked by her clients Robin Tyler and Diane Olson, said to the Yes folks attempting to drown her out: “We don’t believe an amendment can do away with your free speech, and we don’t believe an amendment to the constitution can do away with the right of gays and lesbians to marry.”  Allright then, sister. She closed with the forward-thinking: “We will win, whether it’s in the courts, the legislature, or in the court of public opinion.” 

Again, Tom Ammiano cheered everyone up (you got to love a stand-up comedian who runs for office and wins). “You can’t drown out a big queen,” he called out. “The future is ours, boys and girls, the future is ours.” I tend to agree. Just don’t know how near or distant.

Forgive the fact that I don’t have a telephoto, and you can’t see the shero-to-shero hug that NCLR Director Kate Kendall was giving Therese Stewart, who argued on behalf of the City and County of San Francisco.  (See? Almost obscured by the camerawoman?) I think Stewart should be declared King of the City and County of San Francisco, man.  Her and Shannon Minter. Co-kings.  Wow.  And I’m not even a lawyer or a law student.

This chap’s T-shirt read: “Behind every successful person lies a pack of haters.” You can’t make it out, but the figure on it is flipping the bird.  Man, he sold a ton of those that morning. Um, to our side.  He was inspirationally chipper (”You people got to stop drinking that hatorade!” he called out to the cranky Yes folk.) Here, he was schooling one such hater on the specifics of where God was.  Everywhere, was basically his argument.  He walked away saying “Case closed! Case closed!” And at least to my mind, it was.

Now if only he could have trot around Civic Center and similarly schooled the driver of the homo-hate mobile. This vehicle had to have chewed up at least a half a tank of gas, as it slowly encircled the plaza all morning long.  A truck whose sole purpose was to declare the sin (oops: the SIN!) of homosexuality, complete with an enormous photo of two men kissing, with a circle/slash garland around it, various biblical passages highlit for our edification. The words HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SIN lovingly painted, each word its own rainbow, across the side in foot-high letters. Lord, the time this man spent decorating this vehicle. More time than I ever spent cleaning my parents’ cars in all my high school years, combined. More like, the amount of time a really, really good LGBT Pride float takes. I can only imagine he thought it was an ark. I can also only imagine the charge he gets looking at the 5 foot tall photo of the man-on-man kiss.

Here’s our shero Therese Stewart hopping over a puddle that a troup of plad skirt-clad parochial schoolgirls had only moments before hopped over (they were scenic and photogenic, but also kids, so alas, no pics.)  Why a puddle-jumping shot? I dunno, why not?  Would that the recalcitrant end of the supreme court were as easily surmountable.

And here’s what I liked most: look at these young gals in the foreground looking on at Ms. Stewart there. They had just finished watching this woman’s face plastered on the 20′ x 30′ JumboTron, and even if they didn’t follow every nuance of her razor-sharp argument (fantastic point-by-point summary at the NCLR blog here, in reverse order most recent back to the beginning, 27-odd concise post-lets), they heard the crowd around them cheer her points loudly.  I just like thinking about what that moment might have been like for them.  They totally could grow up to be like her.  I got your PowerPuff Grrl power riiiiiight here, sisters, and it’s real.  And it’s a dyke with close-cropped hair and sensible shoes.  And a brain that deserves to one day be sitting up on the Supreme Court, man.

Parting thoughts: brace for inclement weather, people.  Justice Joyce Kennard: buzz kill par excellence.  Severe case of interruptitis. Man I’d hate to be at a dinner party with her. I am lining up lots of people I don’t want to be in social situations with.  Least favorite elevator ride would include her and No on 8 consultant Steve Smith.

Christopher Krueger, from the Attorney General’s office?  Oh where do we start. I think I’d almost rather have had Bobby Jindal up there arguing for us.  Yes, I said that.  De-ba-cle. Debacle. A splat of Jindalian proportion.  (Splat: opera singer for when you don’t hit your high note.) I hate AG Jerry Brown’s guts for sending this clown in there (that was a song! not a legal strategy!) Will not vote for that man for kaka. Coward shoulda been in there himself if he believed what he said he did. (Hey, LD, let us know what you really think!)

Now I think the whole thing was a cynical political calculation on the part of the future gubernatorial candidate. Hope I’m wrong. But the AG argument undercut everyone else’s, and then when he was to make his point (you know: the reason undercutting the revision vs. argument argument was going to be justified?), he was all “Um” and “You know” and I swear I didn’t hear him cite one precedent.  Seriously.  Whatever water that argument held before he went in there is now all over the floor.  That he went last? Again: de-ba-cle. He was terrible enough as to have been forgettable, but unfortunately, batting last, he remains memorably regrettable.  Kaka poo poo, basically, is my most articulate response to him.  But hey. I’m a jurisprudential neophyte.

[More later, mebbe, after the kids are in bed. Bed, after the kids are in bed. 'Night all.]




6 Responses to “A hastily compiled photo essay of the Prop 8 arguments, outdoor rabble version”

  1. 1 virgotex

    good solid wrap up. I watched live tweets, then was able to get the tv feed for the last hour. Listened more than I watched. So thanks for filling in the details.

    great job

  2. 2 violetta

    oof, what a day! thanks LD for summarizing more than the just the arguments, but also the texture of the morning. you’ve captured well the edgy yet hopeful reality we’re all faced with. it’s sounds as nerve wracking and chaotic as i would have expected. i commend you on your tenacious reporting. yes, i can see the hug behind the camera woman, and that power puff girl bling. so… now…we…wait…and…we…wait. oy. could we hear in less than 90 days? i continue to relish your blog mit coffee mit cream in the ams (and, ahem, for breaking news). keep it up!

  3. 3 marthavictoria1981

    “I got your PowerPuff Grrl power riiiiiight here, sisters, and it’s real. And it’s a dyke with close-cropped hair and sensible shoes. And a brain that deserves to one day be sitting up on the Supreme Court, man.”

    I am now empowered for my day. Thank you.

  4. 4 Lesbian Dad

    Thank you, VT. The nuanced legal arguments are well-attended to by others, to be sure. And welcome back, violetta, glad to know we’re still a part of your morning routine. Edgy yet hopeful, that would be it. Sadly, after watching the proceedings, I’m more edgy than hopeful. But. There’s no question none of us is giving up.

    Welcome marthavictoria1981! Welcome indeed. May the empowerment last as long as possible. Now all we need are Minter and Stewart action figure dolls and Halloween costumes, complete with capes. A Saturday morning cartoon would follow shortly.

  5. 5 lizk

    Wonderful! Thanks for sharing the view-from-the-street, er, plaza. I watched all three hours solo via the web, and am glad to have this taste of spirited melee outside the courtroom.

    From what I saw and what you’ve shared, it sounds like our future may indeed lie out in the streets rather than in the courts. Sad comment on our judicial system, but hopeful for the hearts and minds of the next generation.

  6. 6 Ruffian706

    Oh, Stewart was simply amazing. Amazing. We reserved a room at the school for folks who wanted to watch the arguments, thanks to streaming video and fancy room electronics. Unfortunately I had class at 9 and missed Shannon Minter, but Stewart was simply poetry in motion. The way she was able to stay on point, and always direct her responses to questions back to the point was simply beautiful.

    And yeah…a whole room full of law students agrees with you about Krueger. I can’t tell if he was just horribly inexperienced at arguing in such a context (if so, shame on the AG for sending in someone that green), or if he personally was entirely flummoxed at having to argue such a horribly baseless position (if so, shame on the AG for trying to push forward such flimsy legal theory). Either way, shame on the AG.

Leave a Reply

You must login to post a comment.

    mitrice-web A missing 24 year-old California woman and her family need your help. Please visit findmitrice.info and spread the word & her likeness, particularly to folks in and around California.
    LDonTwitter.final



    The whole LD Twitter enchilada is here. FWIW.


    selectedvideo.final




    El amor vence al odio /Love conquers hate. A heartfelt message from Miriam Mercado, mother of Jorge Steven Lopez Mercado, the young Puerto Rican gay man who was brutally murdered November 13th. His murderer has confessed and will be pleading a "gay panic"/ "trans panic" defense. From Blabbeando, via 365Gay. Andrés Duque, El Blabbeador, directs readers to Boy in Bushwick's coverage of Jorge Steven's death.







    LGBTcivilrights.final




    EQAcrossAM Holding the 14th amendment to its word.



    LGBT people are basically invisible in the survey that is supposed to reflect the diversity of America's population – and that's a big problem.








    Archived material about the 2008 California marriage equality fight and this site's treatment of it can be found at an LD No on 8 page. There you'll also find links to background info on the marriage equality issue & sources of info on current campaigns, like The Courage Campaign's Equality Hub. For ongoing news roundup on national marriage equality issues (updated daily), check out Stop8.org.







    LesbianDad101.final
    Lesbian Dad Lesbian Dad is written by a parent who answers to the name "Baba" and works toward a world in which amor does indeed vincit omnia.

    Still curious? You'll find a ton more on the About page. Or the Glossary. Or the Best of LD. The closest thing to an origin story can be found in this six-post series, excerpted from an essay of mine describing the dawn of my lesbian fatherhood.

    Hispanohablantes: ¿aquí por error? Tengo una página para usted.

    Like to help keep this thing afloat? Ads dent, but don't cover operating costs. I'm grateful for whatever you might...